1 day ago
1. What is the ruling on the saying: “Hate the sin, not the sinner”? 2. Do angels lack free will? 3. If I prayed just 1 rak’ah of witr directly after isha, will I have prayed qiyam al layl?

Ustadh AbdulAziz al-Haqqan
1. As an unqualified principle it is not correct. A Muslim who sins is loved for his iman and disliked for his sin, in proportion to it, as the scholars stated, and if he repents the dislike turns to love. 2. Angels never disobey Allah in what He commands them, and the scholars state that they have will and choice but were created upon obedience. 3. Yes. witr is part of qiyam al layl, its time begins after Isha, and one rak'ah suffices, though more is better.